Meetings & Information




*****************************
****************************************************
MUST READ:
GET THE FACTS!






Showing posts with label Natasha Schull. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Natasha Schull. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 16, 2016

Do casinos improve lives? The Atlantic forcefully says no






The Atlantic, one of America's most influential magazines, has ripped the curtain off predatory gambling in its December edition. It's one of the most compelling and revealing stories ever written about the issue. Please read it and then share it widely on Facebook, Twitter and your email networks.

The country's political establishment (both on the Left and the Right) has forced predatory gambling onto working class, rural and urban Americans alike over the last twenty years, casting it as "an economic engine." One of the major results has been a lower standard of living for almost all of us, regardless whether you gamble or not.

Another tragic result has been the destruction of millions of American lives. Scott Stevens, the primary focus of The Atlantic story, is one of them.

It's inevitable that predatory gambling will be sunset in the United States. It's not a question of if but when.

Best,

Les Bernal
National Director
Stop Predatory Gambling
If you believe what we believe in, please support our work by contributing $10 or more today to help sustain it.

________________________________
Improving the lives of the American people, using education and advocacy to free us of the dishonesty, exploitation, addiction and lower standard of living that commercial gambling spreads.

Monday, August 22, 2016

West Virginia: Lawsuit against Mountaineer dismissed







Lawsuit against Mountaineer dismissed


AUG 21, 2016

STEPHEN HUBA


WHEELING — A judge has dismissed a wrongful death lawsuit that touched on the question of whether casinos and slot machine manufacturers have a responsibility to prevent compulsive gambling by patrons.
The lawsuit against Mountaineer Casino, Racetrack & Resort, filed by the widow of Scott Stevens in 2014, claimed the Hancock County casino had a duty to intervene in the compulsive gambling habits that allegedly drove him to suicide in August 2012.
U.S. District Court Judge Frederick P. Stamp Jr.’s order of dismissal came nearly four years to the date after Stevens fatally shot himself in a Jefferson County park — and a day after Stacy Stevens voluntarily withdrew her case.
Her attorney, James G. Bordas Jr. of Wheeling, could not be reached for comment. Mountaineer routinely does not comment on litigation.
The lawsuit claimed that, from 2007 to the day he died, Stevens was a regular patron at Mountaineer, where he played the slot machines and, over time, became hopelessly addicted to gambling.
To support his habit, he embezzled more than $7 million from his workplace, where he was chief financial officer, and emptied his family’s savings, retirement account and his children’s college funds, the lawsuit said.
Even after an IRS audit discovered the embezzlement and Stevens was fired, he continued playing the slot machines at Mountaineer for 10 more months, never telling his wife about his secret life as he dragged his family deeper into debt, the lawsuit said.
The lawsuit also named as a defendant Reno, Nev.-based slot machine manufacturer International Game Technology Inc. and former Mountaineer parent company, MTR Gaming Group. Its main allegation was that the IGT slot machines used at Mountaineer are“inherently dangerous” and are designed to keep people playing to the point where they can’t stop.
“The products were not a passive medium through which gamblers enacted a pre-existing addiction but, rather, an interactive force that eroded players’ capacity to make reasoned decisions,” the lawsuit said.
The lawsuit also accused IGT of intentionally concealing from patrons algorithms and other design features that govern slot machines’ win-loss functions — features that have been written about in books such as “Addiction by Design: Machine Gambling in Las Vegas” by MIT anthropologist Natasha Dow Schull.
“No other form of gambling is known to manipulate the human mind as much as slot machines,” the lawsuit said. “Playing these machines produces in numerous gamblers a trance-like state in which their ability to make rational decisions is eroded. Players become addicted to a dissociated mental state of diminished self-awareness and the suspension of a sense of time, money value and one’s immediate surroundings.”
Ultimately, the lawsuit stalled on the question of whether casinos and slot machine suppliers have a “duty of care” to protect patrons from compulsive gambling.
Stamp put the question to the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals, the state’s highest court, in order to address motions filed by the defendants to dismiss the case. Justice Brent D. Benjamin, who wrote the opinion, concluded that no duty of care exists under West Virginia law and, therefore, a lawsuit claiming negligence could not be sustained.
Benjamin cited similar cases in Indiana and New Jersey in which courts found that the state’s prerogative in regulating the gaming industry superseded any responsibility on the part of casinos and vendors.
In the case of West Virginia, racetrack casinos such as Mountaineer are already heavily regulated by the West Virginia Lottery Commission, operating under strict rules set by the state Legislature.
“The hardware and software components of the (slot) machines are required to precisely comport with statutory parameters, and ‘each video lottery terminal approved for placement at a licensed racetrack must conform to the exact specifications of the video lottery terminal prototype tested and approved by the commission,'” Benjamin said, citing the West Virginia Code.
What’s more, Benjamin said the state sets aside $150,000-$500,000 annually for its Compulsive Gambling Treatment Fund and maintains an exclusion list whereby patrons with a compulsive gambling disorder can be prevented, either voluntarily or involuntarily, from entering casino premises.
Because legal gambling is so entwined with the state, the duty of care rests with the Legislature not the private sector, Benjamin concluded.
“State law regulates virtually every facet of casino gambling and its potential impact upon the public,” he said. “The state has so thoroughly integrated itself into the provision and operation of the (slot) machines on every level … that its involvement cannot readily be divorced from that of its licensees and key suppliers.”
Stamp said the supreme court’s ruling was “dispositive,”meaning it settled the issue.




Saturday, May 7, 2016

Biggest Losers



Outside In

by

Australians have become the world’s biggest losers thanks to this one addiction



Slot machines, along with other forms of wagering, have made Australians the world’s biggest gambling losers, costing an average US$1,000 per person per year


PUBLISHED : Friday, 06 May, 2016




In the UK this week there was timely relief from the ridiculous debate over whether or not to stay in the European Union, and the surreal civil war in the opposition Labour Party over the eccentric leadership of Jeremy Corbin. It was called Leicester.
The Foxes – Leicester City football club – made football and betting history by winning the Premier League for the first time in their 132-year history. As 5000 to 1 outsiders, Leicester’s victory has created the most massive loss ever in Britain’s gambling industry – an estimated 50 million pounds (HK$561.77 million)




And across this mid sized Midland city of 300,000, at the Crucible, the world Mecca for snooker, Leicester-born Mark Selby battled Jiangsu-born Ding Junhui to become World Snooker Champion. Ding was the first Asian ever to reach the World Snooker Championship final, and was being followed live, deep into the night, by an estimated 100 million snooker fans in China.
As the city of Leicester celebrated this sudden and unfamiliar world attention, a combination of elation and incredulity had locals turning to supernatural influences for the Foxes’ and Mark Selby’s victories: everything in the city has gone miraculously well since the remains of Richard III, King of England from 1483-85 were unearthed in 2012 after being lost for five centuries. Richard was the last British king to die in battle – at Bosworth Field in Leicestershire – and his defeat ended the Plantagenet dynasty, and brought Henry Tudor to the English throne.
Supernatural or not, Britain’s bookies were not amused, calling the Leicester victory “a black armband day”. British media talked of the biggest upset in British betting history. The betting industry has reported big losses before: in January and March 2014 the top five bookies lost 20-25 million pounds, and in January 2015 they lost 40 million pounds. But these losses were on big “accumulator” bets in which individuals managed to pick virtually all of the soccer match winners over a weekend. To lose so much on a single team is without precedent. In offering the 5000 to 1 odds on a Leicester victory, they had said it was as likely as Justin Bieber becoming US President, or Elvis Presley being found alive. They have agreed no longer to offer 5000 to 1 odds. The best odds will in future be 1000 to 1.
For me, as a temporary interloper through the UK, I felt no pity for the bookies. This is a massively profitable industry, and 50 million pounds lost here or there makes only a small dent in consistently huge profits. Last year, the UK’s biggest bookie, the merged Ladbrokes Coral, earned profits of 392 million pounds on the back of revenues of 2 billion pounds. Number two, William Hill, earned 190 million pounds on revenues of 1.6 billion pounds.
But there were two important reminders. First, gambling is a simply huge global addiction. And second, this addiction comes at a huge social cost. In Hong Kong, when we think of gambling, we tend to think of horse racing, but by far the biggest money-earners in the global gambling industry are soccer betting, casinos, lotteries, and mind-numbing slot-machines and pachinko parlours. Recent research by the Economist reveals that the world’s biggest gambling losers come from Australia – losses average over US$1000 per person per year, most of it lost on mindless slot-machines.
The next biggest losers are perhaps surprising. The Economist discovered that Singapore is home to the second biggest losers – losses average US$930 per man, woman and child, with Finland third, losing an average US$600 per capita. Americans lose a comparatively modest US$480 per person, but because of its larger population, it is still home to the world’s biggest gambling losses – estimated at US$119 billion last year. Japanese, with their thousands of pachinko parlours, lost around US$100 billion last year.
By comparison, Hong Kong’s gambling industry looks much more sedate, and much less socially damaging. Even though Hong Kong’s working class men are renowned for their addiction to gambling, with unknown billions spent over the internet on worldwide soccer betting, the vice at home inflicts much less social pain. With the Hong Kong Jockey Club’s monopoly, and gambling restricted to horse racing and the Mark Six lottery, much of what Hong Kong punters lose either goes directly into the government’s pocket, or into charitable contributions. On record total bets last season of HK$108 billion, the government tax take was HK$12.3 billion, and charitable contributions amounted to HK$3.6 billion. And as the monopoly “bookie” in Hong Kong, the Jockey Club’s pool betting system means they never face the 5000-to-1 shock that Leicester City has just created. The size of payouts always depends on the amount bet on any given race, rather than on the intuition of a private sector book-maker. A now-profoundly embarrassed Loughborough bookie who last August scribbled “Pigs might fly” on the 1 pound betting slip of a Leicester football fan who took 5000-to-1 odds on Leicester victory could not happen in Hong Kong.
But this morally awkward global industry, with revenues of an estimated US$420 billion a year, has a “sleeping dog” which few clearly know about, and which was aroused with news that 100 million Chinese stayed up all night in cities across the country to watch snooker hero Ding Junhui’s narrow defeat in Leicester in the World Snooker Championships. Gambling in China is a dark horse industry that is huge, but largely uncounted. China’s thousands of footloose millionaires and senior government officials who have slipped huge amounts out of the country to enrich the casinos of Macau, are surely but the tip of a gambling iceberg.
China’s gamblers are expected soon to make China the world’s largest gambling market, overtaking the US. But numbers are patchy, unreliable, and almost certainly massive underestimates. What impact they will have in future is literally anyone’s guess. Richard Scudamore, chief executive of Britain’s Premier League, was talking about Leicester’s shock victory, but he could have been talking about China, when he said: “We have all become completely hopeless at predicting anything.. No one saw this coming.” In Leicester this week, at least the snooker industry saw China coming.
David Dodwell is Executive Director of the Hong Kong-APEC Trade Policy Group




Davy Glennon: ‘I wasn’t trying to kill myself, but I wanted to kill the life I was living’


Saturday, May 07, 2016
By John Fogarty
GAA Correspondent

But for a text message from his brother, Davy Glennon may have lost his life to the gambling addiction that consumed every part of his being. The Galway hurler’s compelling story is as frightening as it is redemptive.

It’s March 10, 2015. Cheltenham. Mares’ Hurdle. Ruby Walsh and his 4/7 favourite fall at the last to save bookmakers an estimated £40 million.

In a Loughrea betting office, Davy Glennon watches his bet go up in smoke. He stood to make €58,000 had she completed the Walsh/Willie Mullins four-timer.
Instead, he is €2,000 the poorer.
He now knows that €58,000 would have been gone in a matter of weeks. He describes it as “only a loan to give back to the bookies”.
At the time, the €2,000 was relatively small change to him. The previous week, he had disappeared €10,000 in the space of three days.
“I got a loan out from a credit union on a Wednesday. I had a loan from them previously going back years. It was direct debit and then I got a phonecall to say my loan was nearly finished and that my finances with them were good and that anytime again if you wanted a loan we were there to help.
“This was on a Monday. I said to myself: ‘What? More ammunition?’ At the back of my head: I said, ‘No, I can’t? I’m going to gamble this. What did I want the money for?’
“I said to the credit union it was for a car. So I went into them of a Wednesday and I said, ‘I’m looking for a loan’. They said, ‘How much are you looking for?’ And I was thinking €5,000 but then I got greedy and said €10,000. ‘Would you like the money in a cheque or in cash?’ they asked. I said: “Cash.”
“I couldn’t believe my eyes, being given this handy money. So I took the €10,000 out of a Wednesday and by the Friday the money was gone.”
Four years earlier, a 20-year-old Glennon had sold his first car, a seven-year-old Audi A4, for a measly €4,000. The buyer, a man from Sligo, couldn’t believe his luck. Glennon still had a loan on the vehicle but all he wanted was fuel for his habit.
“I was coming out of Tuam and said I’d go into Paddy Power with this money in my pocket. I went in and an hour later it was gone. To be honest, I was so ate by gambling that I really didn’t blink an eyelid. I just thought that was it; it was Monopoly money for me at the time.”
Hurling and gambling. Gambling and hurling. From the age of 16, Davy Glennon knew nothing more. Over the years, the hurling field became a haven for him from his addiction but the status he had earned as an underage hurler of note, as a man who rose to the occasion when Galway needed it most, also blinded him from his ailment.
The more his star rose, the more deluded he became.
“As a county hurler, you think you know more than a Joe Soap. Then pride gets in the way. I won a minor with Galway in 2009, got man of the match. The world was my oyster then. I was going places. You kind of get ahead of yourself. I kind of always knew at the back of my mind that I had a problem but I was in denial. I was too proud to say it to anyone. The pride was getting in the way as well because you thought you were someone but at the end of the day you’re not; you’re only one person.
“I went along then and played with the U21s. I was only coming on as a sub in 2010. In 2011, we won the All-Ireland U21 and I got man of the match again in the final. Things were rolling and you’re an icon at home and in the public eye and that’s when I found the pressure coming on.”
When he won the free that his old housemate Joe Canning slotted over to earn Galway a replay in the 2012 All-Ireland SHC final, he had once again proven he was a man who could be called on at a time of trouble. Only nobody was there for him in his hour of need. Not because they didn’t want to; he just wouldn’t allow it.
“We got to the All-Ireland final, won the free, the hype was around and it got me through another few months, the adrenalin. I was just hanging in by a thread. Hurling and sport is great in one way but in another it kind of held me back, the bit of pride and that, from actually trying to go and get help because of who I was and the talk there would be around club and county.
“I was embarrassed. I was in so deep I couldn’t really get out. I had nowhere to turn, nowhere to look. Who could I tell?”
Glennon was never one for online betting. There was material evidence of all his transactions. And it was always horses and dogs.
“I never did anything in terms of other sports because I never trusted them. I could stay eight or nine hours in a bookies without eating. My diet was gone. An inter-county man, what I was doing went totally against the grain.”
Gambling brought out the worst in him in every aspect. While making headlines at the back of newspapers, he was also making them at the front for a couple of assault charges.
“Addiction takes over your life and I don’t think it was me. It ate me. It had me a totally different person. I was living two lives. I was living the life that everybody wanted to see and I was living my own life. Addiction brings you down and changes you. I didn’t care about anyone. I didn’t care about myself.”
Glennon is emotional when he admits his gambling forced his parents to seek counselling themselves. They attempted to stage an intervention when they organised a meeting with reformed gambler and former Armagh star Oisín McConville in Dublin but Glennon only agreed to see him to plamás them.
Canning noticed all wasn’t well with his friend but Glennon always put a barrier between them. “We were living in Oranmore and he knew to an extent. He was a great help to me, he was on my back, but when you’re in denial you’d nearly fall out with a guy about it because he’d be onto you the whole time asking if you were alright and saying ‘come with me to a match’. I’d be holding back, saying I had to do something at home because all you wanted to do was go to the bookies.
“Other team-mates were on my back but you were pushing them away. You didn’t want them anywhere near you. Then they’re asking if you’re gambling and saying they or somebody else saw you in the bookies and you’re saying ‘that wasn’t me – what’s that got to do with you?’
“Then you lose your friends. I nearly lost my friends. When you lost respect for yourself, it’s very hard to call it a life.”
All the time, Glennon was reconciling with himself that he could deal with it. At the same time, part of him knew things would come to a head. They did on July 5 last year when he lasted just 27 minutes in the Leinster final.
“We had played Laois in the semi-final. I didn’t start because I had an injury from the quarter-final against Dublin. I came on and scored 1-2. All that week before, I was in the bookies all week. I was ate, I hadn’t a penny. I hadn’t the price of diesel to get home, 10 kilometres out of town.
“I was at breaking point at the time but the 1-2, the bit of hurling I was playing, was covering over the cracks. When I crossed the white lines it gave me a bit of freedom from the gambling, it cleared my head but once it was over and I was sitting in the dressing room or on the bus it was ‘where’s my buzz again?’
“The Leinster final was coming up and I got the nod to start and I remember being on the treatment table inside in Croke Park and I hadn’t a brown cent to rub together. I was the joker of the pack, I’d have a bit of craic but I went out and was taken off after 27 minutes. I wasn’t in the game.
“There’s always an excuse whenever you’re taken off but I didn’t have an excuse. I knew I wasn’t in the right place and had been covering over the cracks with good games but this was the last straw. When that board went up with my number, if there was a hole in Croke Park I would have jumped into it. The sick feeling I had in my stomach... it was all over.
“Sitting in the bus going down home, I was saying to myself ‘what am I going to do?’”
Glennon’s parents had stayed in Dublin that evening to attend a concert. He found himself home alone, contemplating taking his own life. It wasn’t without consideration. He had seen the effect of his teammate Niall Donohue’s tragic death in 2013 but he was in such despair that it didn’t matter. Ultimately, it was a text from his younger teenage brother Ronan that inadvertently stopped him.
“He was getting a lift home with one of my cousins and I didn’t realise he was coming home. I said to myself, ‘Will I do it now?’ I hopped into my car and I said ‘where am I going to go? What’s the easiest way out?’ I asked myself what I was leaving behind and the consequences of leaving a young brother, mother and father but you’re so selfish. I was gone selfish. I didn’t care about myself and when you can’t do that you’re not going to care about your friends or your family and the trail you’re leaving behind.
“I didn’t know where I was driving to but I was saying to myself that it was all over and I had to do something. It was 11 o’clock at night when I got a text from him to leave the door open because he would be home. It triggered with me then — ‘what are you doing?’ So I turned on the road and went home. It took my head away from what I was doing. I couldn’t do it. It got me around but I was at breaking point all that week. How was I going to do it? What’s the easiest way? I didn’t want to hurt myself but just get out of town. I wasn’t trying to kill myself but I wanted to kill the life I was living.”
Eventually, he broke down to his mother the following Thursday morning. Donohue’s memory came into his head — there was a life-line. “She knew, but they couldn’t do anything when I wasn’t prepared to do anything for myself. I was going against the grain at home at all times. I said I have to go to Cuan Mhuire.”
It wasn’t until the following day that Canning, who had been worried when he couldn’t make contact with Glennon, discovered his friend had signed himself into Cuan Mhuire’s Athenry treatment centre. Driving up to the building, Glennon had resigned himself to his hurling career being over. The image he had of Cuan Mhuire was of people “going around in bathrobes and slippers”.
Pride still had a grip on him. Sharing a room with seven other addicts, all of whom were detoxing, he felt he hardly had it as bad as them until he started his one-on-one counselling.
“My counsellor was Mick Moloney. He was an absolute gent. He looked at me when I came in and said: ‘You’ve a serious problem. You’re a compulsive gambler and there is no other way about it. You have a serious, serious problem. You didn’t know but you’ve had it for years.’ He actually called it chronic compulsive gambling.
“When he got talking to me in the one-on-one and whether I could stay away from it. I couldn’t. I was gone to a stage when you start missing training, faking injuries and stuff like that. That was when I came to realise I was in denial up to them six weeks. Denial went out the window. I had to say I was a compulsive gambler.”
That was week six of the 12-week programme. Each day, Glennon would wake at 6.30am and have breakfast. There would be mass at 12.30pm, a Rosary at 6pm and lights out at 10pm. They were given tasks to do — “I’d never gone to the bog in my life!”
He hadn’t been religious either but the routine appealed to him. “There were chores that you had to do. You were going back to everyday normal life. I was living a life of controversy and chaos. It was cruel and a pure rat-race. There was devilment in my head to a point where I was gambling outside of my local area of Loughrea, going to Ennis and different places so that people didn’t see me. I was conscious of that. It was in Cuan Mhuire when you get back to reality and basics. You’re doing the routine things. You’re getting up in the morning and getting your breakfast, which I never did.”
Glennon’s only contact with the outside world was at the weekends when family and friends, including his Galway teammates, visited him. Before they played Cork in the All-Ireland quarter-final, he wrote them a letter telling them of his situation, his support for them and his promise to rejoin them in the future.
Special allowances were made for him to watch Galway’s games. As comfortable as the win was over Cork, he was on the edge of his seat for the entirety of the All-Ireland semi-final with Tipperary. The day before the final, he was visited by a bevvy of his team-mates. “That was what they meant to me and what I meant to them. I was near the end, about three weeks out. The boost and drive it gave me, that these boys have the faith in me to come through this... I can’t explain it.”
His heart went out to them the next day when they couldn’t maintain their electric first half against Kilkenny. But for him, the reality of his problem kicked in.
“I was looking at the All-Ireland final and realising exactly what gambling had taken away from me — All-Ireland final day, which you dream of as a young guy. I had that opportunity in 2012 and 2015 if my addiction didn’t take over my life.”
Glennon isn’t currently working but he couldn’t be much happier than at present. He now sleeps at night when he couldn’t before, wrought with worry and guilt.
“I haven’t a penny to rub together, I don’t have a huge amount of money but the €10 or €20 that I do have in my pocket I respect it. I respect it too much to give it to a bookie or some kind of betting situation.”
When Micheál Donohue called him on New Year’s Day to invite him to return to the Galway panel, he was made up. Increment by increment, he has worked his way to a point where he is now doing enough to justify selection in his preferred position in midfield.
Yet he knows the wolf will never leave his door. The job is never to open it. “Going out into the big, bad world and having to pass bookies and hear radio stations where they are temptations and the only person that can hold you from those temptations is yourself. There are days when you get the adrenaline rush. Don’t get me wrong — I loved gambling. I adored hurling and I adored gambling. They were my two biggest things but my gambling took away from hurling. That’s how bad it was.
“Every day is a school day for me. I only take one day at a time. I’m never going to be cured from this illness. I’m a compulsive gambler for the rest of my life. Any gambler who says he’s not isn’t telling the truth. I’ve lost years of hurling that I can never get back. I’m 25 years just gone and I’m just trying to make the most of it because literally gambling took over my life and it ate me. I lost money, my hurling, my talent, what I was good at and the only thing I hadn’t lost yet was my life. That was yet. That was what we’re always taught in Cuan Mhuire — yet. But the next thing down the line for me was my life.”
Cuan Mhuire built him back up and the guidance of the GPA has sustained him, he reports. He sees how they and the GAA are attempting to tackle the scourge of gambling addiction but fears there’s only so much they can do.
“The Paddy Power and others that are out there, they are so big and there are so much profits that it’s very hard to deal with. I saw articles about underage and school games being advertised, which I don’t agree with. You have to be 18 now to make a bet. The temptation is there. Gambling on children, they don’t realise what they can do to someone’s life. I just think that has to be nipped in the bud. It’s out of order.”
Gambling wanted Glennon all to itself but he now shares himself with his nearest and dearest as well as others.
“The respect you have for your family and friends now is the big thing. I would go out of my way to do something for people now because I have that clear conscience back. I have my respect.
“Anything I can do for anyone, I’ll do it, whether they’re a GAA player or not. I know there are people being crippled by addiction and they haven’t come out. People are losing their lives because of it.”
Glennon is the voice but also the message — there is hope.

Walk and cycle for charity

Starting on August 3, a group from Davy Glennon’s parish of Mullagh will walk from Croke Park to Mullagh in aid of Cuan Mhuire and a local group aimed at encouraging mental and physical activity among men who had retired from hurling.
From Mullagh, they will cycle to Cuan Mhuire’s treatment centre in Coolarne, Athenry where they hope to present a hurley signed and presented by GAA president Aogán Ó Fearghail on August 6.
As part of their giving back to the local community campaign, Top Oil have come on board as sponsors.
The four-day event replicates in reverse Glennon’s experience of last year when he checked into Cuan Mhuire four days after he lined out for Galway in a Leinster final.
The fundraiser will be launched in Cuan Mhuire, Athenry next Saturday 3.30pm.
In 2015, Glennon was among 490 people treated in Athenry.
It costs €1m per annum to run the facility but after Government funding and resident contributions there is a shortfall of between €100,000 and €150,000.



Thursday, March 24, 2016

Letter to AG Maura Healey on Penn National's Deceptive Online Marketing Practices





Below is our letter today to Attorney General Maura Healey requesting that her office take swift action to protect Massachusetts consumers from Penn National's deceptive and unfair online marketing practices as reported in today's Boston Globe.

I encourage you to contact her office by email or a hard copy letter, urging her to act against these fraudulent practices. 

Thanks.
Best,

Les Bernal,
Stop Predatory Gambling
March 23, 2016

Attorney General Maura Healey
Office of the Attorney General
c/o Gaming Enforcement Division
One Ashburton Place
Boston, MA 02108

Dear Attorney General Healey:

On behalf of Stop Predatory Gambling (SPG), I am writing to request that your office act swiftly to stop the unfair and deceptive marketing practices being used by Plainridge casino in their online marketing program.

As reported by The Boston Globe on March 23rd, Plainridge’s parent company Penn National has designed a fraudulent online slots game that creates an illusion of success with the intent of luring more citizens to use real slot machines.

According to the story:

“If the games look the same and sound the same, but the payback of one is much lower, then that’s misleading,” said Natasha Dow Schull, an associate professor at New York University and the author of Addiction By Design: Machine Gambling in Las Vegas.
Schull said online casino sites have a bait-and-switch quality to them because their large payoffs condition players to expect the same at the casino.

The goal of online slot machines, a growing trend known in the casino industry as social gaming, is to “prime your system for gambling — to hook you in,” she said.


The real slot machines inside Penn National’s casino are designed mathematically so users are certain to lose their money the longer they play. At the same time, the machines are literally designed so citizens cannot stop using them, exploiting aspects of human psychology and inducing irrational behavior.[1] Every feature of a slot machine - its mathematical structure, visual graphics, sound dynamics, seating and screen ergonomics - is designed to increase a player's "time on device" – which means how long a person plays.[2]  (See Figure 1 below)

Figure 1: Addiction By Design by MIT Professor Dr. Natasha Schull, Pg. 112

 

No single act of government creates more inequality of opportunity than its promotion of gambling. Bringing about major reform on this public policy includes stopping the unfair and deceptive marketing practices used by commercial gambling operators such as Penn National.

For additional information on the issue, please contact me at (202) 567-6696. Thank you for your attention to this important consumer protection issue.


Sincerely,

Les Bernal
National Director
Stop Predatory Gambling

________________________________

[1] Natasha Dow Schull, PhD, Addiction By Design, Machine Gambling in Las Vegas, (2012), available at http://press.princeton.edu/titles/9156.html

[2] Natasha Dow Schull, PhD, Beware: Machine Zone Ahead, Washington Post, July 6, 2008, http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/07/04/AR2008070402134.html
____________
Build a more humane and just society: sunset the policy of government-sponsored gambling because it's dishonest, financially damaging to citizens and contributes to rising inequality of opportunity.





Saturday, July 25, 2015

Predatory Gambling In the Crosshairs




Predatory Gambling In the Crosshairs



It used to be that if you wanted to play slot machines, you’d have to go to Las Vegas or Atlantic City.

Now, they’re everywhere.

stop









And not everyone is happy about it.

A grassroots movement is emerging to reverse the nationwide penetration of predatory gambling.

Grassroots organizers want to get rid of it. And by it they mean almost all forms of government sponsored gambling — slot machines, casinos, lotteries.

And they are starting to make a splash in the media.

Last year, comedian John Oliver did a 15 minute piece ripping apart lotteries.

Later this year, a documentary — Out of Luck — will be released exposing the downside of lotteries.

MIT Professor Natasha Schull has written a book length expose on slot machines titled Addiction by Design: Machine Gambling in Las Vegas. (Princeton University Press, 2012.)

CBS News’ 60 Minutes featured Schull on a 2011 piece titled Slot Machines: The Big Gamble.
And now, the grassroots movement has taken a page from the anti-tobacco warriors.

They’ve started a Predatory Gambling Liability Project.

And it’s headed by a former Assistant U.S. Attorney — Michael Fagan, with support from legendary tobacco litigator Richard Daynard and the Public Health Advocacy Institute.

“Most every successful social movement has had four pieces to win,” Les Bernal of Stop Predatory Gambling told Corporate Crime Reporter in an interview last week. “Legislation, education, direct action and litigation. As a movement over the last eight years, we have tried to build momentum in all four of those areas.”

“On the litigation side, for the first time in modern American history, there is a major case against casino interests that was filed in West Virginia, in Wheeling, in August 2014. It is currently pending in West Virginia federal court. The lead attorneys are Terry Noffsinger and James Bordas. The plaintiff is Stacy Stevens. She’s the widow of Scott Stevens. He was a successful CFO. He worked for a multimillion dollar family owned business in western Pennsylvania. He was very successful.”

“Then he went to Las Vegas to a conference, was introduced to slot machines. He started playing the slot machines locally at the casino in Wheeling. He started losing. He embezzled millions from his employer to feed his slot machine addiction. This isn’t like some Joe on the street. He was an incredibly successful family man, businessman — everything you would want in a person.”

“He got hooked on these slot machines. In August 2012, he drove to a soccer field in his hometown — a soccer field he helped raise money for — called the EMTs so they could pick up his body, and he shot himself in the park.”

“His wife is suing the casino owner and the slot machine maker — IGT. They are putting the slot machines on trial. It’s the best case that has been brought.”

“The litigation piece is happening,” Bernal said. “And we’ve launched the Predatory Gambling Liability Project. It’s chaired by a former Assistant U.S. Attorney out of St. Louis — Michael Fagan. We have more than 30 attorneys from across the U.S. including Richard Daynard, the legendary tobacco litigator. He heads the Public Health Advocacy Institute.”
What about direct action?

“People went into casinos, put money into the slot machines and the people just sat in the chairs,” Bernal relates. “We were technically playing the machines, but we weren’t playing them the way the casinos want us to play them. It was a protest that got some press.”
Bernal says that predatory gambling “extracts enormous amounts of wealth from everyday people.”

“And it’s not just the poor — middle class, low income families,” Bernal says. “It’s probably one of the biggest wealth extractors in our society. It destroys families. Unlike alcohol or drugs, you don’t know what is happening to this person until they are done with everything.

You don’t see it. People who are alcoholics will tell you — with alcohol, after ten beers, you stop. Your body cuts you off. But with gambling, you chase. People stand up six or seven days straight at these casinos — losing everything they have. Chasing means you go to the casino with $100. You go through that. Do you hit the casino ATM or go home? People who chase their losses go to the ATM. Mathematically, the machines are rigged against you. But if you show your propensity to chase, the casinos will come after you like no other business in America with exploitive tactics. And they get away with it because government is a part of it.”

Bernal says that people who have been victimized by predatory gambling are fighting back.

“In Illinois, Melynda Litchfield is our national victims advocate there,” Bernal says. “She was a talented, successful nursing supervisory for an intensive care unit for a major hospital outside of Chicago. She had been there for 27 years, happily married with three children. The state of Illinois located a casino near her house — about a twenty minute drive from where she lived. Over time, she became addicted to slot machines. She became so addicted to these machines that she embezzled hospital supplies from where she worked and sold them on eBay just to feed her gambling addiction. About three years ago, she got divorced. She was caught by the hospital. She almost took her own life twice. She lost her nursing license for a year. She has now made this issue her calling. She’s going out and standing up for the millions of Americans who are being exploited everyday. We refer to them as the expendable Americans.”

Bernal says that both the Republican and Democratic parties are bought off by the predatory gambling industry.

“A lot of establishment politicians say things like — I don’t like gambling, but it’s here,” Bernal says. “We have to do it. They will try to distance themselves from it. Yet they will take all of the campaign money. They will allow it to come into their state.”

“Deval Patrick in Massachusetts quarterbacked it in,” Bernal says. “Martin O’Malley in Maryland quarterbacked it in. Andrew Cuomo in New York. A lot of Democrats are pushing it.”

“This will be the first time we have big gambling candidates in the Presidential field. Chris Christie in New Jersey. Hillary Clinton had Jan Jones on her finance committee. Jan Jones is one of the key government affairs people for Caesars Casino.”
There are exceptions.

“Marco Rubio was a strong opponent of state run gambling in Florida,” Bernal says. “I would expect Bernie Sanders to speak out against it.”

“The new Massachusetts Attorney General, Maura Healey, won her 2014 primary largely on this issue,” Bernal says. “She was opposed to casinos. She has been publically strong against casinos.”

What about the labor unions?

“The labor unions have been advocates for predatory gambling in the United States,” Bernal says. “They see it as an organizing tool to get labor union members. The building trades want the casinos because they want to build them. Some of the unions, like SEIU, want to organize the workers. Never mind how the casinos make their money — they just want to add to their ranks.”

- See more at: http://www.corporatecrimereporter.com/news/200/predatory-gambling-in-the-crosshairs/#sthash.vZS0TMIJ.dpuf