Meetings & Information




*****************************
****************************************************
MUST READ:
GET THE FACTS!






Showing posts with label Minnesota. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Minnesota. Show all posts

Friday, May 29, 2015

Tyrone Herman gets 10 years for operating $20 million Ponzi scheme to fund Gambling Addiction





Tyrone Herman gets 10 years for operating $20 million Ponzi scheme

Tyrone Herman was accused of stealing from family and friends.

Sunday, May 10, 2015

Appeals Court Sends Casino Dispute Back to District Court, Again



Appeals Court Sends Casino Dispute Back to District Court, Again


A long-running dispute over revenues from the Fond du Luth Casino is headed back to U.S. District Court after a ruling Friday by a three-judge panel from the 8th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals.


Updated: 05/08/2015 3:48 PM
Created: 05/08/2015 3:46 PM WDIO.com 

                 
For the second time, a federal appeals court has sent a dispute over Duluth casino payments back to district court, saying the district court did not rule on all of the six factors it had been ordered to consider.

Friday's ruling from a panel of three judges on the 8th District Court of Appeals is the latest in the six-year-old dispute between the City of Duluth and the Fond du Lac Band of Lake Superior Chippewa. This case deals specifically with payments of revenue from the Fond du Luth Casino that the city says should have been made from 2009 to 2011.

The band stopped making payments to the city in 2009 after concluding that its agreement with the city violated federal law. In 2011, the National Indian Gaming Commission issued a notice of violation confirming that the agreement was illegal, but a federal judge ruled in 2011 that the band should still pay nearly $10.4 million for the years 2009, 2010, and 2011.

The band appealed the 2011 ruling, and in 2013 the appeals court sent the case back to U.S. District Court for Minnesota to consider six factors. However, the appeals court now says the district court did not consider one of the factors: the question of whether Congress intended "to ensure that the primary beneficiaries of Indian gaming operations are to be the tribes themselves."

The appeals court has now sent the case back to district court to consider the sixth factor.

Though the notice of violation said federal law requires tribes to be the sole beneficiary of casinos, the City of Duluth has argued that federal law does allow Indian gaming revenues to be used to fund local government operations. However, the appeals court says there is nothing in the record to suggest that the agreement between the city and the band was ever intended to solely cover the cost of city services.

The ruling said that the record indicates property taxes for a non-Indian owner of the casino property would have been $180,930 for 2010, far less than the $6 million the city is seeking for that year. The ruling also said the city has provided almost no evidence regarding the costs of services to the casino and admitted during oral arguments that it had never calculated the costs.

The band had paid 19 percent of gross revenue, totaling $75 million, to the City of Duluth from 1994 to 2009. Mayor Don Ness and other city leaders have repeatedly expressed frustration with the loss of revenue for the city.

Earlier this year, U.S. District Court Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly denied the city's attempt to have the NIGC's 2011 notice of violation overturned. The city also lost a federal lawsuit that had tried to prevent the band from placing the Carter Hotel property adjacent to the casino into trust.


Saturday, August 17, 2013

City Clerk Steals $167,000 to Fuel Gambling Addiction




Leonard receives probation, fines
By Staff reports
Moose Lake Star-Gazette


On Friday, Mary Angela Leonard, former clerk of the city of Willow River charged with embezzling over $167,000 from the city, was sentenced to 21 months in the prison. Her prison time was stayed for 20 years probation on the condition that she spends 30 days in county jail with additional restitution to be made to the City of Willow River. Judge James T. Reuter presided over the trial.

Leonard wrote and forged checks under the mayor’s name from the City of Willow River during May of 2009 to August of 2012. She then cashed the checks and logged checks onto the computer under a legitimate account using the money to obtain property or services.

The prosecuting attorney requested a statement be made on behalf of the City of Willow River. Judge Reuter granted the request.

The statement, written by Willow River City Councilman Chris Ketchmark, was read as follows by the attorney, “Our close knit, small community of 410 suffered a devastating loss and betrayal at the hands of the defendant. A financial loss in excess of $167,000 in a town our size is quite substantial.

This loss has delayed or prevented important projects and needs in our community. These include but are not limited to proper maintenance and repairs of our streets, repairing our sewer ponds, repairing our water lift station and purchasing equipment to do such repairs, maintenance and snow removal.

The money this defendant admits to stealing from our city was not there when we needed it for infrastructure, let alone when the flood of 2012 ravaged citizens, homes and businesses there. This was money contributed by every hard-working, honest, tax paying citizen of our county.

“A betrayal and crime of this magnitude has had an emotional and psychological impact on the citizens of Willow River and those of us involved in its government. We are asked multiple times per week about how and why this crime happened. Those are questions only one person can answer. All we can tell the people we represent is that we’re doing our best to see that the defendant pays for her crimes and that it never happens again. As Councilmen, we are left to apologize and carry the burden of a crime we had no idea was happening and would never have guessed would happen by someone we trusted. Every financial decision we make as a council will now be second guessed and scrutinized because of something one defendant did. Our citizens were left feeling suspicious and untrusting of their government, again because of one person’s actions. At times it has felt like citizens were more upset at their government than the actions and crimes of the defendant.

"What outcome would we as a council and citizens of Willow River like to see in this case? Due to the repeated nature and length of time over which the thefts took place, we would like to see jail time and restitution in the maximum amount possible. As I stated, over 400 people have been affected by these crimes, not a nebulous “entity” but the City of Willow River. Every man, woman, and child in our town was stolen from and harmed by this defendant.

"Your Honor, I am a compassionate and reasonable human being. That being said, I feel very strongly that this defendant be punished to the maximum extent allowed. Gambling addiction is a disease, stealing multiple times over a period of years to support this disease, to enable this addiction is unacceptable. Stealing is not a disease. Theft is not a disease. Betraying your fellow citizens and those that hired you is not a disease. The first instance of stealing was a mistake, after that it was a calculated choice. Thank you. Dr. Chris Ketchmark.”

Leonard’s attorney stated that Leonard was looking forward to this day so she could express herself.

Mary Leonard was then allowed to make a statement, “I just want to say how sorry I am. I stole a great deal of money from people I care about and put a burden on my family. I am glad today is here and I am in recovery and can start to make amends.”

Judge Reuter stated to Leonard, “We see this from time to time especially in this community where there are lots of opportunities with the casinos. People go and win and that seems to put a hook in them and each time there is an expectation to win. It becomes an addiction. The tragedy here is that there are victims, people in the government. People start to suspect those in government and they have to respond to questions of how and why. This has an impact on a small community and the people of Willow River. This case has impacted their impressions on people in government. We can hold people accountable. The city thinks one year in county jail is acceptable.

“It is concerning to me that in 2004, you went through the program for gambling addiction and you are aware of your gambling problem. But you are a lady with no track record, clean as a whistle.

What is the right thing to do? I think 20 years of probation to insure nothing like this ever happens again is rational. You have no criminal record. The addiction was controlling your behavior, but this is not to dismiss you.”

The maximum fine of $30,000 was waived with Judge Reuter adding that this would create undue hardship and the minimum fine of $50 was imposed. Judge Reuter added that $100,000 was paid out from insurance to the City of Willow River. He also stated, “Regular payments toward restitution will be made (to pay the approximate balance of $65,000) and that funds in Leonard’s pension account will be applied to restitution as well.”

Other conditions imposed are that Leonard comply with recommended gambling programs and attend regular meeting regarding her addiction. Leonard is not to gamble, enter any establishment that allows gambling and remain law-biding. Judge Reuter added, “If you screw up, you will go back to jail.”

Leonard will begin her jail time on August 19.

http://www.mlstargazette.com/story/2013/08/15/news/leonard-receives-probation-fines/701.html


Willow River clerk charged with $167k theft from city

Leonard said all of the money she took went to Grand Casino Hinckley or the Black Bear Casino in Carlton County or to pay bills, with most going to the Hinckley casino. She denied having any money left.


http://www.presspubs.com/pine_city/news/article_fac642a4-9263-11e2-9718-0019bb2963f4.html


Sunday, July 14, 2013

Fond-du-Luth casino lowers gambling age to 18



Fond-du-Luth casino lowers gambling age

4:27 PM, Jul 10, 2013

File still of gambling table Photo by: Getty Images/Philippe Lopez
 
DULUTH, Minn. - You don't have to be 21 anymore to place a bet at the Fond-du-Luth casino in Duluth.

The casino has dropped its minimum wage for gambling to 18. The casino's general manager, Maurice Ojibway, says the primary reason for the change is to make it consistent with the Black Bear casino in Carlton. Both are operated by the Fond du Lac Band of Lake Superior Chippewa.

The Duluth News Tribune says the Fond-du-Luth casino raised its minimum age to 21 in 1992 when it started serving alcohol on the gaming floor.


http://www.kare11.com/news/article/1031386/396/Fond-du-Luth-casino-lowers-gambling-age



 

Wednesday, April 17, 2013

The Folly of Funding with Overstated Gambling Revenues that never appear

Massachusetts included overstated Gambling Revenues to fund capital projects.

Doesn't take the brightest bulb to recognize the Folly!



Racinos solve problem

April 15, 2013
Fairmont Sentinel
 
To the Editor:

In an effort to solve the Minnesota Vikings stadium funding woes as well as to provide new revenue to state government, I support racino legislation that would allow slot machines at Minnesota's horse tracks.

Racino is our best hope of paying the state's portion of the Vikings stadium without tax increases. I was never interested in using tax dollars to pay for stadium construction, but Gov. Dayton wanted this to happen with e-pulltabs and didn't research how poorly they fared in Iowa. E-pulltabs didn't work in Iowa, and they aren't working in Minnesota either.

In Minnesota, e-pulltabs are approximately 95 percent short of projections we received during the stadium push. Previous estimates found that slots at Minnesota tracks would generate $150 million per year in Minnesota and create another $400 million in economic impact for the state.
In the past, racinos have been strongly opposed by Minnesota's Native American tribes, which have been successfully operating casinos for many years.

Nowhere in Minnesota's Constitution does it say our tribes should have an exclusive monopoly on gambling revenue.

This racino legislation would help our ag industry, give many Minnesotans a good paying job, and make the horse industry viable once again while solving our stadium's revenue collection problem.

State Rep. Bob Gunther,

R-Fairmont

http://www.fairmontsentinel.com/page/content.detail/id/524779/Racinos-solve-problem.html?nav=5044

 

Thursday, January 17, 2013

Gambling on Gambling Revenues


Funding a 'public' project based on unpredictable Gambling Revenue might not be the best fiscal plan.


Vikings stadium: Lagging funds from gambling concern lawmakers


By Patrick Condon
Associated Press
Posted: 01/16/2013

A leading Democratic state lawmaker said Wednesday, Jan. 16, that he is growing more concerned about the reliability of tax revenue from electronic gambling machines that is supposed to help pay for construction of a new Minnesota Vikings stadium.

"I'm more concerned than I was before the hearing," said Rep. Joe Atkins, DFL-Inver Grove Heights, after the House Commerce Committee -- which he chairs -- met to review the recent rollout of the electronic pull-tab games in bars and restaurants.

Tax revenue from those games is supposed to fund the state's $348 million share of the $975 million Vikings stadium slated for downtown Minneapolis. But the tax revenue from the games, which started to become available in September, fell short of projections by about half through the end of 2012: While $35.2 million was projected to come in, the games returned only $17.2 million in tax revenue.

Backers of the new games said they need time to get more popular and expand to other bars.

"We would ask for your patience," said Allen Lund, executive director of Allied Charities of Minnesota. Legal gambling in bars is operated by Minnesota charitable organizations, from youth sports clubs to veterans groups.

"When all the distributors who want these products have it to sell, those numbers will go up exponentially. If we could get some patience, we would appreciate it," he said.

Atkins, who voted for the Vikings stadium plan when the Legislature approved it in the spring, pointed out that lawmakers have only a few months if it becomes necessary to retool the bill. He said it was still too early to make that call, pointing out that the stadium bill did include backup revenue sources in the form of a sports-themed lottery and a stadium suite tax.  But Atkins also said he believes that even recently downgraded revenue projections on the games still are too optimistic.

State gambling regulators initially had projected that the games would be available at 2,500 sites around the state by October. But today, they are available at only 120 sites; the 2,500 goal has been pushed to July.

"I think, at this point, that 2,500 by July seems very aggressive," Atkins said.

Tom Barrett, executive director of the state's Gambling Control Board, said charitable organizations have been slow to sign on to the electronic games because they are faithful to longtime distributors of paper games. He predicted that interest would accelerate once his agency approves more distributors for electronic games, beyond the two now allowed to operate.

So far, the availability of the electronic games has not lessened the popularity of traditional paper pull-tabs, which some had predicted. Barrett said sales of paper games rose in the last fiscal year and are on track to rise another 8 percent in the current one.

The groundbreaking for the new stadium is tentatively set for October, with opening hoped for by 2016.

Atkins instructed Barrett to apprise lawmakers on a regular basis of revenue collections on the games. He pointed out that the current session will end in May.

"Our window of opportunity, if changes become necessary, closes in four months," Atkins said.


http://www.twincities.com/politics/ci_22389677/vikings-stadium-lagging-funds-from-gambling-concern-lawmakers

Monday, December 3, 2012

Minnesota becomes first state to sell lottery tickets at gas pumps, ATMs




Among the massive mountain of ever-growing evidence about how government's experiment with gambling has failed, comes this latest avalanche from the Minnesota Lottery: citizens in that state can now buy lottery tickets at ATMs. As they take cash out of their savings or checking accounts, they can now lose some or all of it on virtually worthless government lottery tickets. This is the same lottery that uses puppets that appeal to children for their marketing campaign.

http://www.mailtribune.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=%2F20121203%2FBIZ%2F212030302
 

Minnesota becomes first state to sell lottery tickets at gas pumps, ATMs

All buyers need are a driver's license, debit card and a cellphone
 
http://www.mailtribune.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=%2F20121203%2FBIZ%2F212030302

Friday, November 30, 2012

Gambling Addict gets prison for embezzling $1M

Gambling Addiction increases with proximity.



Land O'Lakes worker gets prison for embezzling $1M

  • Article by: PAUL WALSH , Star Tribune
  • Updated: November 29, 2012
"Pathological gambler" stole from Land O'Lakes.
 
 
A onetime payroll supervisor for Land O'Lakes Inc. has been sentenced to more than two years in prison for embezzling more than $1 million to feed her addiction as a "pathological gambler" and cover other personal expenses.

Cynthia C. Jacobsen, 58, of Brooklyn Park, was sentenced Wednesday in federal court in St. Paul to two years and two months in prison and ordered to pay $1,035,955.58 in restitution. Jacobsen pleaded guilty in July to mail fraud.

In her plea agreement, Jacobsen acknowledged that from 2008 until May 2012, she entered her daughter's name into the Arden Hills dairy company's payment system as a vendor and authorized 489 payments to her. The checks were mailed to Jacobsen's home, where she and her daughter lived.

Jacobsen forged her daughter's signature, then "cashed the checks and used the money on various items including gambling," federal prosecutor Chris Wilton wrote in a presentencing filing with the court. "It is clear that the defendant has personal issues including a very real addiction to gambling."

The defense explained in its presentencing filing that Jacobsen sought an escape in casino gambling after her son-in-law died on Valentine's Day 2008 following a diabetic coma. Jacobsen's income dropped when she missed work because of knee surgery.

"Ms. Jacobsen's gambling quickly spiraled out of control," defense attorney James Becker wrote.

"Although spending time in casinos was a somewhat effective respite from her real-world problems, her gambling habit added to them, and she soon was having difficulty covering even basic expenses."

Desperation, Becker added, forced Jacobsen to steal from her employer.

After her embezzlement was exposed, Jacobsen was assessed and deemed to be "a pathological gambler," Becker continued. He said she has been participating in Gamblers Anonymous and "is committed to recovering from her disease."
 
 
 

Ex-Land O’Lakes Worker Gets 2 Yrs. for Embezzling $1M

Gavel

In addition to her prison sentence, Cynthia Jacobsen was ordered to pay $1.04 million in restitution.

by Jake Anderson
November 29, 2012
A former accounts payable supervisor for Land O’ Lakes has been sentenced to two years and two months in prison for embezzling more than $1 million from the Arden Hills-based agricultural cooperative, Minnesota’s U.S. Attorney’s Office said Wednesday.

Cynthia Jacobsen of Brooklyn Park, who was charged in June with one count of mail fraud, pleaded guilty the following month.

In addition to handing down Jacobsen’s prison sentence, U.S. District Judge Donovan Frank ordered her to pay $1.04 million in restitution, the U.S. Attorney’s Office said.

While working as an accounts payable supervisor, Jacobsen authorized payments to vendors that provided services to Land O’ Lakes. In her plea agreement, she admitted that from 2008 through May 2012, she entered her daughter’s name into the company’s payment system in the place of a legitimate vendor. She authorized 489 illegal payments, which were mailed to her residence, according to the U.S. Attorney’s Office. Jacobsen also admitted to forging her daughter’s signature in order to cash the checks for her personal use.

Jacobsen’s attorney wrote in court documents that her crime stemmed from “a perfect storm of guilt and gambling.” Her daughter’s husband died in 2008 after being in a diabetic coma for more than two years. His home health care costs proved “financially disastrous,” and knee surgery rendered Jacobsen unable to work. She “craved an escape,” her gambling “quickly spiraled out of control,” and she embezzled funds after being unable to cover basic expenses, according to court documents.

http://tcbmag.com/News/Recent-News/2012/November/Ex-Land-O-Lakes-Worker-Gets-2-Yrs-for-Embezzling

Monday, August 13, 2012

Inside the richest native American tribe




Inside the richest native American tribe in the U.S. where casino profits pay $1m a year to EVERY member

  • Payouts coming out of the money the Shakopee Mdewakanton Tribe makes through its highly profitable casinos
  • About 460 people live within the tribe
  • Between Mystic Lake and the Little Six Casino - tribal revenues are thought to be nearly $1.4billion
By Daily Mail Reporter



America's richest Indian tribe has 99.2 per cent unemployment -- and it's all voluntary, tribal leaders boast.
There's little need for any member of the Shakopee Mdewakanton Tribe to work. Each adult in the 460-person American Indian nation receives more than $1million a year - for doing nothing.
The payouts are the windfall from lucrative casinos and resorts that the tribe runs on its reservation in Scott County - about 45 minutes southwest of Minneapolis-St Paul.
Shakopee Mdewakanton
Wealthy: Members of the Shakopee Mdewakanton Tribe are the richest American Indians in the nation, thanks to $1million annual payouts to each member

The New York Times reports that the payments, $84,000 a month to each adult, were revealed in divorce filings involving one of the tribal members.
The Shakopee keep modest homes on the reservation, but nearly every driveway sports at least one luxury car.



Tribal members usually have multiple homes and have been known to take vacation for months at a time.
Many choose to take up expensive hobbies. They are big game hunters and breeders of thoroughbred horses. All of the children attend private schools.
Lucrative: The Mystic Lake Casino Hotel includes five restaurants, a 600-room hotel, convention center, 2,100 seat showroom, 8,350 seat amphitheater and a golf course.
Lucrative: The Mystic Lake Casino Hotel includes five restaurants, a 600-room hotel, convention center, 2,100 seat showroom, 8,350 seat amphitheater and a golf course.
It's a remarkable turnaround for a group once hunted down by US Army soldiers -- before finding refuge in Minnesota.
The source of the almost unbelievable wealth is a pair of luxury casinos and resorts the tribe has built on its land - drawing tens of thousands of gamblers from the Minneapolis-St Paul region, and across the state.
The Mystic Lake Casino Hotel is build on a man-made lake. It includes five restaurants, a 600-room hotel, convention center, 2,100 seat showroom, 8,350 seat outdoor amphitheater and a top-notch golf course.
The theater venue competes for major touring acts with venues in Minneapolis and St Paul.
Shakopee Mdewakanton
Weak: Some tribal elders worry that the money is making the Shakopee complacent and soft
The Mystic Lake Casino is the fourth-largest Indian casino in the nation.
Combined with the tribe's Little Six Casino, revenues reportedly make up the lion's share of Minnesota's $1.4billion gambling profits, according to the Times.
The tribe has used the money to generous donations to other Indian tribes - lending money and giving grants. It's always used the money to gain clout in the community.
The Shakopee people have donated more than $243million since 1996 and lent out nearly $500million.
Swimming in cash: Between Mystic Lake, pictured, and a second casino, tribal revenues are thought to be nearly $1.4billion
Swimming in cash: Between Mystic Lake, pictured, and a second casino, tribal revenues are thought to be nearly $1.4billion
Among the major grants is a $12.5million gift to the University of Minnesota to build a new football stadium and endow scholarships for American Indian students.
Not everyone sees the windfall of money as good. Some tribal elders worry the $1million salary is making members complacent.
'Why dig a hole when you don’t need to dig it -- when you can pay someone to dig a hole?' Keith B Anderson, the tribe’s secretary and treasurer, told the Times.
'Instead of budgeting a dinner and movie, you can go to dinner and a movie and have dinner again and see another movie, but you can’t see enough movies and dinners to spend all your money.'


Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2187456/Shakopee-Mdewakanton-Tribe-Casino-revenue-pays-member-1million-year.html#ixzz23QXgheNM


$1 Million Each Year for All, as Long as Tribe’s Luck Holds

Jenn Ackerman for The New York Times
The Mystic Lake Casino swells the population of the reservation to the size of a city on weekends. More Photos »
Multimedia

Today, the Shakopee Mdewakanton are believed to be the richest tribe in American history as measured by individual personal wealth: Each adult, according to court records and confirmed by one tribal member, receives a monthly payment of around $84,000, or $1.08 million a year.

The financial success of the 480 members of the Shakopee Tribe — whose ancestors 150 years ago were hunted down, slaughtered and eventually exiled from Minnesota — derives from their flourishing casino and resort operation, which on weekends swells the population of their tiny reservation to the size of a city.

“We have 99.2 percent unemployment,” Stanley R. Crooks, the tribe’s president, said as he smiled during a rare interview. “It’s entirely voluntary.”

While the Shakopee tribe continues to prosper, casino gambling in much of Indian Country — which tribes say is the only economic development tool that has ever worked on reservations — has in recent months come increasingly under threat, stirring worries that the long lucky streak is over.

The primary anxiety is competing casinos being hurriedly opened by states in pursuit of new revenue. But more menacing, tribes say, is a sophisticated and growing movement to legalize Internet gambling under state laws that would give those states the potential power to regulate and tax online gambling even on reservations.
      
Further, the current expansion of legalized gambling in the United States, and the prospect of more to come, could not have arrived at a worse moment for tribes, because after 25 years of booming profits, the tribal casino business has suddenly gone flat. The vast majority of tribes have not become rich. Instead, casinos have become a baseline economic necessity, lifting thousands out of poverty by serving as a primary source of income and employment.
      
“My worry is this may be the beginning of the end, that in the push to increase state and federal revenue we are putting at risk the groups who continue to need Indian gaming,” said Kathryn Rand, co-director of the Institute for the Study of Tribal Gaming at the University of North Dakota. During the past year or so, Maine, Ohio, Kansas and Pennsylvania have all opened large casinos, and in Maryland, pent-up demand caused a traffic snarl miles long— during the middle of the night — at the opening of a new casino in June.

Among other states, Massachusetts recently approved casino gambling and New York is moving in that direction. In November, Oregon voters will decide whether to open their first casinos while Michigan voters will determine whether to expand gambling there as well.

While the new commercial casinos turn over much of their revenue to state and local governments, tribal facilities do not pay direct state taxes because of the tribes’ status as sovereign nations.

That status, however, has become a concern for tribes as it relates to legalized online gambling, which is expected to transform the industry by allowing people to play casino games like poker on mobile devices whenever and wherever they want.

Attempts by some states to tax all online gambling revenue, which tribes regard as an unacceptable violation of their sovereign status, have set up a collision course. “We are very adamant that people understand we are governments, and expect to be treated like governments,” said Ernie Stevens Jr., chairman of the National Indian Gaming Association.

Delaware, in June, became the first state to legalize casino-style gambling on the Internet, a move that followed a Justice Department interpretation last December that opened the door to online gambling. All this has come as unwelcome news in the $26 billion tribal gambling industry. In recent years, a number of casinos have closed, the days of building elaborate new complexes appears to have ended, and efforts to build new casinos off reservation — and nearer metropolitan areas — has proved largely unsuccessful.

Even some of the most successful gambling tribes have had to reduce or eliminate gambling revenue payments to members.

The Mashantucket Pequot Tribal Nation in Ledyard, Conn., for instance, has stopped making individual awards that had once been as high as $120,000 a year after it amassed $2 billion in debt. And members of the Mohegan tribe in Uncasville, Conn., who operate Mohegan Sun, had been receiving about $360,000 annually before seeing significant reductions in recent years.
Since 1996, the tribe has donated $243.5 million, including $120 million to poorer tribes, and lent $478.5 million.
      
It is Scott County’s largest employer, and has contributed tens of millions of dollars for roads and to schools and hospitals. “We’re doing very well,” Mr. Crooks said. “We feel we have an obligation to help others. It’s part of our culture.”

Measuring the tribe’s charity however, is difficult because the amount it doles out to members is secret. (The $84,000 a month figure that each adult in the tribe receives comes from a 2004 divorce case involving a tribal member, but was confirmed by a current tribal member as still correct.)

Alan Meister, an economist who compiles tribal gambling data, said Minnesota’s 18 tribal casinos earned a combined $1.4 billion in 2010, although the Shakopees’ portion of that is unclear. But even if the tribe accounted for nearly the entire $1.4 billion, its philanthropy would compare well with corporations, even though the tribe receives no tax write-offs for giving.

For example, the tribe’s $28.5 million in charitable cash contributions in 2010 was more than those of several Minneapolis-area Fortune 500 companies, including the 3M Corporation, which had 2010 revenue of $23 billion, and U.S. Bancorp, which had $19.5 billion in revenue in 2010, according to the Minnesota Council on Foundations.

Despite its wealth, however, the Shakopee reservation has few mansion-size homes, although most families have at least one high-end car in the driveway. Many tribal members own large second homes off the reservation and nearly everyone sends children to private schools. Expensive hobbies like thoroughbred breeding, big game hunting and elaborate trips — which sometimes last for months — are common.
      
Families say it is difficult to teach children the value of money when everyone knows no one will likely ever need to work.

“Why dig a hole when you don’t need to dig it — when you can pay someone to dig a hole?” said Keith B. Anderson, the tribe’s secretary and treasurer, who once worked for Target as an industrial designer. “Instead of budgeting a dinner and movie, you can go to dinner and a movie and have dinner again and see another movie, but you can’t see enough movies and dinners to spend all your money.”

Thursday, June 28, 2012

Fighting to keep low wage jobs




LETTER: Tribe not concerned about air quality

To the Telegram: Mike Wiggins Jr., chairman of the Bad River Indian Nation claims to be concerned about “air quality” in an article published June 13 when it comes to iron ore mines, yet workers employed in the Bad River Casino are forced to work in a smoke-filled workplace, which is more devastating to human health than any mine would be.

To the Telegram:
Mike Wiggins Jr., chairman of the Bad River Indian Nation claims to be concerned about “air quality” in an article published June 13 when it comes to iron ore mines, yet workers employed in the Bad River Casino are forced to work in a smoke-filled workplace, which is more devastating to human health than any mine would be.

Mike Wiggins Jr. doesn’t want to discuss the quality of air in casinos ... this was his only response to me when I tried to broach the issue with him.

Putting an end to smoking in a casino is very simple — a few cheap signs would do the trick.

Mike Wiggins Jr. has lost all credibility when he talks about how an iron ore mine would cause a deterioration in air quality when the smoke in the casino where he has the power to actually do something for an improvement in air quality, for improving human health, and he does nothing. What a hypocrite Mike Wiggins Jr. is.

The real reason Mike Wiggins Jr. opposes this iron ore mining operation so close to his smoke-filled casino is the Bad River Casino would have to compete with the high wages of the mining industry as casino workers rush to get out of this smoke-filled casino for better wages and a healthier working environment.

Come on Mike, tell the truth; it is the high wages of the mining industry you really are opposed to that you are so loathe to have to compete with.

By the way, Mike, how much do you pay casino workers for risking their health working in your smoke-filled casino?

Does Mike Wiggins Jr. not know about the cancers, heart and lung problems and complications for those suffering from diabetes attributable to second-hand smoke?

I challenge Mike Wiggins Jr. to respond to me and explain: Why, if he is so concerned about air quality, he continues to allow smoking in the Bad River Casino?

And what about all of these politicians opposing this mine depriving workers of better pay and a healthier working environment than that provided by the Indian Gaming Industry, which — coincidentally? — contributes very lavishly to their campaign coffers?

And what about all these so called “environmental organizations” consisting of muddle-headed middle class intellectuals who use this anti-mining crap as a ploy to stuff envelopes begging for contributions complaining about “air quality” when they sit in their smoke-free offices and remain silent as over two-million workers across the country are forced to work in these smoke-filled casinos?

Alan L. Maki,
director of organizing,
Midwest Casino Workers
Organizing Council
Warroad, Minn.

http://www.superiortelegram.com/event/article/id/67551/group/Opinion/

Monday, April 9, 2012

Metro casino getting little political support

Reminiscent of Bread and Circus instead of sound fiscal policy.

Metro casino getting little political support
Scout.com
By JOHN HOLLER
VikingUpdate.com

With the Vikings stadium bill remaining in a holding pattern as politicos continue to hem, haw and harrumph their way into inaction, a new player in the game has come up with a stadium funding proposal -- but one that isn't being received in the spirit in which the offer was made.

For years, the State of Minnesota and resident Native American tribes have maintained a hard and bitter peace when it has come to gaming in the state. In terms of state-run casinos, the battle has been ongoing for years. The Native American tribes were granted casino rights as part of a reparation process that was a concession to the crimes committed against Minnesota Indians over time.

There are currently 20 casinos dotted throughout Minnesota, but none of them are located in Minneapolis -- the largest city in the state and a natural tourist attraction for outstate Minnesotans heading to "The Cities." It is a prime piece of gambling real estate that has yet to be tapped. There are casinos in Prior Lake that draw millions of people every year, but, a downtown Minneapolis casino has been the prized property that remains untapped for a big-time casino that would be likely be the biggest thing casino gaming in Minnesota has ever seen.

The White Earth Indian Nation made an offer this week to pay the state's entire $400 million commitment to construct a new stadium on the current Metrodome site. One of the poorest tribes in the state, the White Earth proposal comes with a hitch. In exchange for the payment of the state's share of the stadium cost, the state would grant the White Earth Nation a metro casino.

There are 20,000 members of the White Earth Nation and, being located in far northern Minnesota, the gaming profits other tribes have enjoyed thanks to their proximity to the population centers of the state haven't been afforded them. However, the reception to the plan, unveiled by tribal chairwoman Erma Vizenor, isn't being well-received by the state.

As big a hot potato as the stadium issue has been for Minnesota lawmakers, putting a casino in Minneapolis has been molten political lava. House Speaker Kurt Zellers (IR-Maple Grove) quickly denounced the plan, as did Senate Majority Leader David Senjum (IR-Rochester).

At a time when Vikings fans are praying against hope that somehow the current stadium bill that appears to be life support will pass, it would seem that if someone wants to get the state off the hook (again) from paying for a stadium, perhaps the White Earth proposal shouldn't simply be dismissed as impractical.

The White Earth proposal is a long shot at best -- even its staunchest supporters would admit that -- but it's something. At a time when "nothing" appears to be more of a buzzword than "something" on the stadium issue, any proposal that offers something that meets the wish of the state to not using any state tax money on a stadium would seem like a positive for stadium supporters. Instead, it would appear the idea has been shot down before the ink on the paper being distributed to legislators has even dried.

Sunday, April 8, 2012

Embezzlers these days more likely to be women

Embezzlers these days more likely to be women
Article by: ABBY SIMONS , Star Tribune Updated: April 7, 2012
With motive and opportunity, women are behind most of the state's high-profile cases since '08.

As a veteran criminal defense attorney, Craig Cascarano has defended scores of women accused of embezzlement.

After his own secretary wrote more than $12,000 in checks to herself with law firm money, the Minneapolis attorney also knew what it felt like to fall victim to one.

In an era dominated by male Ponzi schemers who have become household names by bilking investors out of millions, more women are being accused and convicted of stealing from their employers -- ranging from churches and mom-and-pop shops to massive financial institutions.

In Minnesota, five of the six most prolific alleged embezzlers last year were women, according to the 2011 Marquet Report on Embezzlement. The U.S. Sentencing Commission says that embezzlement is the only offense nationwide where women outnumber men.

The Boston-based Marquet Report, which analyzes prominent embezzlement cases with losses of more than $100,000, found that women made up 64 percent of the alleged perpetrators nationwide. The most common form of embezzlement was forgery or the unauthorized use of company checks.

"It's really been a problem, and it's a significant problem," Cascarano said of the high number of women who embezzle. "But I don't know if it's indigenous to women. It seems that when I have a woman client who's charged with some sort of theft or embezzlement, clearly they have carte blanche authority with the money."

Among Cascarano's clients was Pam Dellis, a former state Revenue Department auditor who is now serving a five-year federal prison sentence for conspiring with two female family members to defraud the state of nearly $2 million to feed a gambling addiction.

Unconventional wisdom

Cascarano said the trend is easy to spot. Its origins are not.

Of 29 high-profile Minnesota embezzlement cases the Marquet Report studied since 2008, 18 were carried out by women, with victims ranging from law firms to school districts and even a child abuse resource center.

In all, the Minnesota women allegedly took nearly $3 million.

Of the top 10 cases nationwide last year, six perpetrators were women -- although women stole less money overall than men.

Aside from Dellis, Minnesota's most prolific embezzlers include:

• Kathleen Cicmil, 56, an ex-real estate agent sentenced to nearly two years in prison for stealing $300,000 from the Hibbing real estate company where she worked for 18 years.

• Former Minnesota Power executive Susan Kay Thompson, 53, who allegedly stole more than $218,000.

• Ex-Freeborn County Commissioner and real estate agent Linda Kae Tuttle-Olson, who stole just under $1 million from the escrow accounts of her clients.

• Alberta-Chokio School District employee Liane Claassen, who stole $275,000 by giving herself regular pay raises and hiding money electronically between accounts.

Prosecutors say Ava Marie Hamilton, 51, of Coon Rapids, stole $550,000 from Theros Restaurant Group, where she worked as a bookkeeper, because she was addicted to gambling. She is scheduled to stand trial for nine felonies this month.


"Conventional wisdom has always been that the white-collar criminal is always this white male, middle-aged upper management guy. Year after year after year, it blows that conventional wisdom out of the water," said Christopher Marquet, who developed the embezzlement report and said women have been responsible for two-thirds of the cases for four years running.

Gambling a key motive

Motive and opportunity are the main factors as to why more women embezzle, said Mark Osler, professor at the University of St. Thomas School of Law and a former assistant U.S. attorney in Detroit.

Women dominate "pink-collar" professions, such as bank tellers, office workers and bookkeepers, Osler said -- jobs that entrust them with handling money.

Motives, he said, run the gamut from health care costs to drug addiction. Chief among them is gambling, which accounted for 22 percent of cases in 2011, according to the Marquet Report.

It makes sense given that most embezzlers in the end have nothing to show for it, said Elizabeth George, CEO of the Duluth-based North American Training Institute, which deals exclusively with gambling addiction.

"Every time I pick up the paper and see a trusted and valued employee embezzle $250,000, I wonder if that person has a gambling addiction," George said.

She added that most women who embezzle often keep track of what they spend, with the intention of paying it back.

"It doesn't mean it's not a crime, but I think there is some uniqueness with someone who has a gambling addiction versus someone who makes a theft of opportunity," George said. "Where some would buy things for their house or take a trip, a woman with a gambling addiction has nothing to show for it.

Cascarano estimates that 90 percent of the cases he has seen involve a gambling or alcohol problem. Rarely, he said, is greed a sole factor. Large-scale Ponzi schemes like those run by Bernie Madoff or Tom Petters, who scammed investors out of millions, are rare.

"Rarely do I see somebody come in and say, 'I was completely greedy and I took $2 million,' " he said.

That's also why it's rare to see women pay the money back, Cascarano said, calling restitution a "pie-eyed concept." They're likely stealing because they don't have any money in the first place, he said. His ex-secretary, who received a two-month jail sentence, is among them.

"We've seen zero," he said. "Not even an apology."

Marquet Report

Saturday, March 31, 2012

Politicians placing bets

COLUMN-Politicians placing bets: David Cay Johnston

By David Cay Johnston

March 30 (Reuters) - Politicians in both parties are betting that allowing more gambling will make them winners at the polls by raising revenue without appearing to raise taxes.

Governors Andrew Cuomo of New York and Steve Beshear of Kentucky, both Democrats, each want seven casinos.

In Kansas, where the state owns casinos, Governor Sam Brownback, a Republican, wants more gambling money to pay down state debts.

In Minnesota, Governor Mark Dayton of the Democratic-Farmer-Labor party wants more gambling to finance a new stadium for the privately owned Vikings football team.

Florida legislators are mulling three casinos, one in Miami. Illinois lawmakers may allow a casino in Chicago.

In Texas, Governor Rick Perry says he opposes more gambling. Yet eight years ago he called the legislature into special session to allow gambling at the gas pumps to help finance schools (). He lost that bet.

Egging on these and other politicians is anti-tax crusader Grover Norquist, who has made "tax" the vilest four-letter word in American politics. Norquist wrote Texas politicians a letter in January saying that more gambling is better than more taxes. ()

As a longtime student of gambling companies and their regulation, I find these developments troubling. People who want to play should have an honest place to wager. But states should only allow, not encourage, gambling. Basic government services should not depend on gambling revenue, as Perry's school finance proposal did.

No matter how much gambling the law allows, taxes on the money players lose will never be enough to finance the government services on which jobs and private wealth creation depend.


$24 BILLION IN 2010 REVENUES

Gambling generated $24 billion for the states in 2010, about 2 percent of their total revenues, data collected by the Rockefeller Institute of Government shows (). Thanks to its lottery, New York got the most gambling revenue, $2.7 billion, more than Nevada and New Jersey combined.

Tax revenues from gambling are down in both West and East Mammonopolis, in part because of a weak economy. In the west, Nevada gamblers lost $3.8 billion last year, down 12 percent in real terms from 2000, according to the University of Nevada (). In the east, Atlantic City players lost $3.3 billion last year, down 39 percent from their inflation-adjusted loss of $5.4 billion in 2001, according to the state of New Jersey. The only growth is in betting near home, which the industry calls "convenience play." Slot machines took more money from players in Pennsylvania than Atlantic City last year.

Nelson Rose, the Whittier College law professor who developed the theory that America is riding its third historic wave of gambling, says, "we are decades away from market saturation" for convenience gambling.

The first two gambling waves ended in scandals, the first between 1820 and 1840 because of dishonest games, the second in 1890 because the nationwide Louisiana Lottery corrupted politicians.

While the third wave has yet to crest, a potential new scandal lurks in proposals to initiate legal online betting.

The U.S. Justice Department issued a formal opinion in December that the Wire Act, a law long-thought to bar Internet gambling, applies only to sports betting. ()

This means that states running the Powerball and Megamillions lotteries can operate multistate online poker and other Internet betting.

But how will states know if online players are adults? My 1992 book "Temples of Chance" named 13- and 14-year-old children who Atlantic City casinos plied with liquor, limousines and luxury suites. How will the states keep underage gamblers using their own money -- or Mom and Dad's credit cards -- from online poker?


WHO BENEFITS?

Another issue is who benefits from more gambling and who may be maneuvered into supporting it. Consider the way Cuomo has framed a casino expansion proposal.

New York has nine racetracks with slot machines, called racinos. By proposing only seven casino licenses, Cuomo initiated a variation on musical chairs, where two or more operators will end up without a license when the music stops. Want to bet whether this approach encourages political donations and quiet favors?

The giant Asian gambling company Genting Group won the contract for the Aqueduct racino in Queens last year. Now, Cuomo has tapped Genting to build the nation's largest convention center there, which it says it will do without subsidies.

I doubt many people would fly to New York to visit mundane Ozone Park, an hour's subway ride from Manhattan's Broadway shows, Fifth Avenue shopping and Times Square.

At the same time, Cuomo is proposing to close the Javits convention center in the heart of the city, alarming Manhattan hotel and restaurant owners, as it should.

Now let's connect the dots.

Genting would make more money if instead of a convention hall in Ozone Park it erects a large open space for a full-blown casino with baccarat, blackjack, craps, pai gow and poker. But a casino requires legislative and voter approval, which may not be easy to get.

Cuomo, by threatening to close the Javits center, has given Manhattan hotel and restaurant operators an interest in persuading state legislators and voters to make sure Ozone Park becomes a huge casino complex and Javits stays open. That way their income from Manhattan conventioneers would not be at risk.

I find it most curious that any politician trying to avoid tax increases would consider a casino operator whose profits will go to Malaysia instead of staying in-state.

People in New York, and elsewhere, should ask: What value do offshore casino operators add? Why not license American gaming companies? Or local investors? What motivated Cuomo to shun Indian casino operators, like the Oneida Nation with its well-run Turning Stone casino near Syracuse?

And all Americans should ask what the odds are that more gambling will promote an industrious, thrifty society. And does it make sense for your tax savings to depend on how many of your neighbors make a losing toss of the dice?

Sunday, March 25, 2012

They’re shackled by money, power and greed....

Capital Chatter: White Earth casino plan still lingering at Capitol
By: Don Davis, Worthington Daily Globe

ST. PAUL — Minnesota legislators talk little about a White Earth Band casino proposal to increase state revenue, but the band leader says she will continue to push it as lawmakers struggle to find money for everything from a stadium to schools.


To answer one of the critics’ nagging questions, White Earth hired former Minnesota Chief Justice Eric Magnuson to look into constitutionality of the state allowing the northwestern Minnesota band to build a Twin Cities casino. He opined: “Legislation authorizing casino gaming, including slot machines, would survive a challenge based on the Minnesota Constitution.”

But even tribal Chairwoman Erma Vizenor, who continues to push hard for a new casino, admits the plan likely would land in court, Nathan Bowe of Detroit Lakes Newspapers reported.

The small Shakopee Mdewakanton Sioux Band, operator of the state’s biggest casino, Mystic Lake, probably would be joined by other tribes in fighting the White Earth proposal.

They’re shackled by money, power and greed, and you can quote me on that,” Vizenor said. “But White Earth is doing the right thing for our people and the state of Minnesota; the resistance and pressure and attacks will not thwart me.”

Besides other casino-owning tribes, conservatives who oppose gambling could challenge the plan in court.

Gov. Mark Dayton has said he opposes using casino revenue, including allowing slot machines at horse-racing tracks, for stadium construction funding because a court case could delay the money for five years.

Magnuson said there has “never been a general prohibition on gambling in either the Minnesota Constitution or state statutes.” But, he added, Minnesota courts have not ruled on questions about the plan to allow the state lottery to extend its oversight to casinos.

“It is our opinion that the state could, if it so chooses, define casino gaming as a lottery to avoid any constitutional issue of whether such gaming is, in fact, a lottery as that term is used in the Constitution,” Magnuson said.

Vizenor pointed out that state and tribal governments have worked together on casinos in Wisconsin, Michigan and other states.

White Earth says the state could received up to $1 billion in the first five years of a Twin Cities casino operation.


Davis works for Forum Communications Co., which owns the Daily Globe.

Friday, March 23, 2012

Any excuse!

Legislators use any excuse to expand gambling from propping up the horse racing industry that's on life support to funding a stadium.

Do they believe the revenue falls from the sky?

Minnesota Senate panel rejects 'racino' proposal
By Doug Belden

A plan kicking around the Capitol for years that would allow slot machines at horse-racing tracks got a vote in a Senate committee Monday, March 19, and went down 8-5.

Majority Leader Dave Senjem, R-Rochester, sponsor of the "racino" bill, said afterward that the defeat does not mean the issue is dead this session. "Racino is part of the Capitol fabric," he said. "It'll stand as long as this building stands."

Senjem said he thought the vote would be closer but counted it a victory of sorts that there was a vote at all after years of the issue floating in limbo. "There's been many years we couldn't get a hearing," he said.

John McCarthy, executive director of the Minnesota Indian Gaming Association, testified against the bill in front of the State Government Innovation and Veterans committee, arguing it would cost jobs at tribal casinos and represent an expansion of gambling that would be hard to stop.

"I think you always wind up in a better position when you've had a vote and it's gone down in a major committee," McCarthy said after the vote. But "it's far from over. This thing is going to continue to pop up."

Racino has been promoted as a funding source for the state's portion of a new Vikings stadium, and Monday's hearing comes at a time when some lawmakers are expressing doubts about the ability of electronic pull-tab gaming to supply sufficient revenue for the state's stadium share.

But Senjem said tying his bill to a stadium is "not even on the radar." He said the measure is needed to shore up the state's ailing horse industry.

Under his bill, the tax revenues - which Senjem said would be between $87 million and $120 million per year - would have gone toward paying back more than $2 billion in state aid owed to schools.

But Senjem wasn't too firm on that, agreeing later to support an amendment from Sen. Julianne Ortman, R-Chanhassen, that would direct the money not to the school shift but to a new college scholarship for

. (Staff)students who earn at least a 3.0 grade point average.
Ortman's amendment passed, as did another one from Sen. Dave Thompson, R-Lakeville, that would subject any racino plan to a vote of the public in the county where it would be located.

That would mean voters in Scott County, where Canterbury Park is located, and Anoka County, which houses Running Aces, would get a say after the Legislature had taken action, Thompson said.

Several GOP committee members voted no on the bill, as did several Democrats. Senjem said backers knew going in there would be Republicans who would oppose gambling on moral grounds.

He and other supporters argued racino would not represent an expansion of gambling in the state since Canterbury and Running Aces already have card clubs.

"You don't always win the first time," Senjem said of Monday's vote. "We always knew it was going to be difficult."

Tuesday, March 20, 2012

Subsidizing Horse Racing

Regardless of location, horse racing is DEAD and demanding subsidies. The arguments are the same.

Racino makes a bad bet
After hours of testimony Monday, a Minnesota Senate committee gave the racino idea the first vote it has seen for years. Unfortunately for backers, the vote was "no." The bill, defeated on an 8-5 vote, would have greenlighted slot machines at racetracks. Supporters said the measure would save the state’s horse industry and pump new life into the racetracks. Opponents warned racinos would suck revenues and jobs away from charitable gaming and casinos. Tom Prichard, executive director of the Minnesota Family Council, added that slot machines are “more addictive than crack cocaine.” -- Jennifer Brooks

Saturday, March 3, 2012

"...government becomes hooked on gambling just like a compulsive gambler...."

This is the floodgate that Governor Slot Barns opened in Massachusetts --

With stadium plan, Dayton carries on unfortunate legacy of ‘gambling governor’
By Steven Dornfeld

To help fund a new Vikings stadium, DFL Gov. Mark Dayton wants to borrow a page from the political handbook of the late Gov. Rudy Perpich – to expand legalized gambling in Minnesota.

Perpich, who gave Dayton his political start, was about as straight an arrow as they come. However, during his 10 years as governor, he presided over the greatest expansion of legalized gambling in state history. As biographer Betty Wilson noted, Perpich is remembered by some as “the gambling governor.”

Under Perpich’s watch, the state:

•Expanded charitable gambling in 1978 by permitting the use of paddle wheels, tip boards and raffles (he allowed the bill to become law without his signature).

•Enacted legislation in 1983 to allow the construction of Canterbury Downs and legalize racetrack betting, capitalizing on a constitutional change approved by the voters a year earlier.

•Approved a constitutional change in 1988 that allowed the creation of the Minnesota Lottery.

•Signed compacts with Minnesota’s11 Indian tribes in 1989 that allowed the tribes to go into the casino business and gave them a lucrative monopoly – no strings attached.

At the end of the 1989 legislative session, then-Sen. Dean Johnson of Willmar said, “The gambling floodgates are open.” By 1992, Minnesota was “the largest casino gaming center between Nevada and New Jersey,” according to a State Planning Agency report.

Electronic pull-tabs
Now Dayton and his legislative allies want to build on this unfortunate legacy, proposing the legalization of electronic pull-tabs to fund the state’s $398 million share of a $975 million stadium. The Minnesota Department of Revenue has estimated electronic pull tabs could bring in up to $42.7 million annually.

Questions about the expansion of gambling may be the least of the political hurdles facing the latest stadium proposal.

For much of the state’s history, legalized gambling consisted largely of low-stakes bingo games in church basements. In 1947, Gov. Luther Youngdahl made a political name for himself by passing legislation to drive out slot machines that had crept into Minnesota and become popular attractions in many resort communities.

However, over the last three decades, legal gambling increasingly has become a part of the state’s culture. It started with a 1981 law allowing nonprofit and charitable organizations to sell pull-tabs, which forged a regrettable link between gambling and youth athletic programs, among others.

Last year, pull-tabs generated nearly $1 billion in sales and the lottery sold another $500 million in tickets. As for the 18 tribal casinos, who knows how much they raked in? In 2007, the most recent year for which figures are available, these casinos attracted 24.6 million visitors, three times as many as people as Minnesota state parks.

Striking it rich
The unfortunate message, amplified in advertising for the lottery and Powerball: The way to get ahead is not through education and hard work, but rather by buying a ticket and striking it rich.

“How would you like a chance at a million big ones?” asked the Minnesota Lottery’s website. “ Check out our new Million $$ Match TV spot and see if any of these scratching styles could bring you a million dollars instantly!”

Perpich, who championed the lottery proposal, justified it as a way to generate money for economic development and conservation programs. Now Dayton and his allies see the electronic pull-tabs as they only way to build a football stadium and hang onto the Vikings.

If you’ve ever sat in a sports bar and watched patrons fill multiple baskets with the pull-tabs they’ve ripped through, it may be difficult to imagine electronic pull-tabs being any more seductive, if not addictive.

Addiction experts estimate that 160,000 to 214,000 Minnesotans struggle with compulsive gambling, which can threaten family relationships, empty retirement savings , lead to criminal behavior and ultimately destroy lives.

If you’ve followed the news even casually over the years, you know there are church staff members who have embezzled from their employers, elected officials who have written bad checks and law students who have robbed banks – all to support their gambling habits.

As for the state, it’s much like the problem gamblers within our borders. As a William Thompson, a professor at the University of Nevada, once observed, “What happens in gaming is that the government becomes hooked on gambling just like a compulsive gambler.”

Saturday, February 4, 2012

MN GOP Says Casino Oversight Is Nonexistent

MN GOP Says Casino Oversight Is Nonexistent
By Ryan Gustafson, News Reporter

Several Casinos throughout the state are facing scrutiny at the Capitol, as Minnesota Republicans say they are no longer being audited.

When it comes to inspecting Minnesota's casinos, some lawmakers say the state has been letting it ride.

No inspections took place last year, and Mystic Lake and Grand Casino haven't been inspected since 2007.

Public Safety Committee Chair Tony Cornish isn't alleging any fraud, but says he's troubled by the lack of oversight.

Rep. Cornish says, "Someone said, 'can you prove there's any fraud at all? Aren't you getting excited about nothing?' But how do you discover fraud without inspections."
Like everything at the Capitol, there are some politics at play here.

Indian Casinos have typically been big supporters of the DFL, and talk about state-run gambling being used as funding for a new Vikings stadium has drawn controversy.

Rep. Cornish says, "This year the Indian community turned out to be the largest donator to the DFL party, and the most vocal criticism of what we want to do with inspectors came from one of the DFL members in my committee and there's going to be certain people trying to protect the Indian community from more closer inspectors, but it's something we got to do. They got to play under the same rules that our Legions and VFWs do."

Representatives from the Mdewakanton Tribe, which runs Mystic Lake Casino in Shakopee, say Indian casinos throughout the state already have strict oversight in place, including regulations from the National Indian Gaming commission.

They add that Minnesota does not have primary regulatory authority over their gaming operations.

But Cornish says it's high time the state got involved.

Sunday, January 22, 2012

Slots get little or no state review

Slots get little or no state review
Article by: TONY KENNEDY , Star Tribune

The state's biggest casinos have gone years without inspections, even with three agents on the job. In contrast, Wisconsin, with a staff of 15, follows detailed procedures and audits every casino once every 18 months.

Slot machines and blackjack tables at Minnesota's Indian casinos have been operating with little to no state scrutiny since at least 2008, records show, including zero slot machine inspections at Mystic Lake Casino in Shakopee, by far the state's biggest gambling house.

Slots at Grand Casino Hinckley and Grand Casino Mille Lacs have gone four years without inspections, which are supposed to guarantee compliance with state-mandated payout ratios. And there were no blackjack inspections at any of the state's casinos in 2008, 2009 and most or all of 2011, according to documents reviewed by the Star Tribune.

The state agency with authority to inspect tribal casinos -- the Alcohol and Gambling Enforcement division of the Department of Public Safety -- has attributed the decline in inspections to budget constraints. But even with three full-time agents assigned to Indian casinos, it has not reviewed any tribal casino audits since 2005. And unlike its counterparts in neighboring states, the agency has no manual of procedures for slot and blackjack inspections.

"Who is looking out for the people of Minnesota here? It's not happening," said Rep. Steve Drazkowski, R-Mazeppa, whose staff has been investigating the matter since last June.

Sen. Mike Parry, R-Waseca, chairman of the State Government Innovation and Veterans Committee, said he will call a hearing on the issue this year.

"I just feel we need to get to the bottom of this," Parry said. "It's absolutely uncalled for that our enforcement department is not fulfilling its obligation."

John McCarthy, executive director of the Minnesota Indian Gaming Association, said there has never been any question about the integrity of Minnesota's tribal gaming and that the tribes have complied with all regulations. Besides oversight from the state, Indian casinos in Minnesota are regulated by the tribal governments themselves, the Bureau of Indian Affairs, the U.S. Department of Justice and the National Indian Gaming Commission.

"There just is no problem,'' McCarthy said. "It's the most regulated gambling in the country.''

Wisconsin, where a similar industry of Indian casino gambling is thriving, has a much more rigorous inspection protocol.

Using a staff of 15, the Wisconsin Division of Gaming follows detailed procedures and a tight schedule of five-day compliance audits at every casino once every 18 months.

Wisconsin agents inspect 10 percent of slot machines on those visits while also observing and inspecting card games. They always do a follow-up audit, the state's compliance chief said in an e-mail to a Minnesota legislative staffer.

Protecting games' integrity

Steve Knudson, administrator of Wisconsin's Gaming Division, wouldn't comment on specific inspection findings but said they are "necessary to maintaining the integrity of casino gaming in our state."

Parry and Drazkowski said the purpose of sending state inspectors to the floors of the casinos is to protect the integrity of the games.

"It's to provide deterrents for mischief in a variety of areas," Drazkowski said.

Slot machine payouts, which are controlled by software, are mandated by law to be a minimum of 80 percent to 95 percent of what goes in over the lifetime of the game. Among other things, inspectors are supposed to ensure that casinos follow control standards on removal and replacement of the software.

When blackjack games are reviewed, inspectors are supposed to run a variety of checks on cards in use by dealers, storage of cards, security of cards, dealing practices, table bets, tipping by patrons, table supervision and other elements.

A fresh start

Michele Tuchner, the new director of Minnesota's Alcohol and Gambling Enforcement, said she is considering a fresh approach to fulfilling the agency's casino inspection obligations. Hired in October from the State Patrol, she has been discussing how to accomplish more with limited resources.

After talking with the staff, she said, she has concluded, "We've kind of been a little neglectful of casino inspections.''

For starters, she said, inspectors immediately will resume the practice of reviewing audited tribal financial reports on gambling. The first stop will be Mystic Lake, which recently notified the agency that its latest reports are available.

To be sure, state inspectors have reported few problems, even when they were doing hundreds of game inspections a year, Tuchner said. When concerns have risen, the tribes have worked to address them.

Jim Arlt, Minnesota's former acting director of gambling enforcement, said in a letter to Drazkowski last August that since 2008 the agency had limited its inspections to "primarily being reactive to complaints."

The result was the near elimination of slot machine inspections. In the four-year period stretching to the end of 2007, just 35 of 15,150 slot machines at the state's seven largest Indian casinos were inspected, according to Department of Public Safety records obtained by Joe Marble, committee administrator for the Minnesota House.

Arlt had put a priority on blackjack inspections for 2011 after they were revived in 2010, but by mid-year no blackjack inspections had been completed. In October, when Tuchner took over, Arlt's goal was unmet, she said.

As recently as 2007, the state had a different strategy for casino inspections, putting slot machines first.

"Video games of chance [slots] are the largest form of gambling in the tribal casinos and inspections of those devices are given priority,'' then-Public Safety Commissioner Michael Campion wrote in a January 2008 letter to a state representative who inquired about card game inspections. Campion said there had not been recent inspections of blackjack because of the emphasis on slots.

100 percent inspections

Like Wisconsin, South Dakota invests heavily in on-site casino visits, Marble's research showed. Even if a tribal gaming commission operates its own testing program, the state tests 20 percent of gambling devices at a casino. When South Dakota audits privately owned casinos, it inspects all slot machines.

When Minnesota signed gambling compacts with the state's 11 Indian tribes starting in 1989, the tribes agreed to pay $13,636 each year for state oversight.

The combined annual payment to the state is $150,000.

Parry said it might be appropriate to review whether the contribution is still adequate. The compacts were signed in perpetuity with no revenue sharing for the state.


"If Gambling Enforcement has a problem, they need to talk to the Legislature about it or else get out there and do their job," he said. "Just saying, 'Well, we don't have the time or we don't have the manpower,' that just doesn't cut it."

Tuchner, the new enforcement director, said her staff is already striving for more efficient ways to oversee tribal gaming.

A pilot project in cooperation with the Red Lake Band of Chippewa is giving state inspectors access to a computer database that tracks slot payouts en masse at the tribe's casinos. If it goes well, the Leech Lake Band of Chippewa is prepared to join the effort.

"I do feel that the inspections are a responsibility of this division," Tuchner said.